Brother of Murder Victim Reacts to Verdict - WICU12 HD WSEE Erie, PA News, Sports, Weather and Events

Brother of Murder Victim Reacts to Verdict

Posted: Updated:

The choice was between first and third degree murder. After a day and a half of testimony, Erie County Judge John Garhart ruled that 49-year-old Robert Quick committed first degree murder when he killed 35-year-old Aderian Page. 

Page's family members packed the courtroom, it was the verdict they hoped for.  Jermaine Nixon spoke on behalf of the family, "I lost my brother, my mother lost her son, so I feel like his family should go through the same things and feel the same things."

Both sides agreed to the facts, that Quick brutally beat 35-year-old Aderian Page to death with an aluminum baseball bat last February 22, in Quick's Pennsylvania Avenue apartment. The victim's body was not found until several days later in a snowy nearby yard.

The big question did Quick intend to kill the man he called his crack cocaine dealer when he came to collect a 500 dollar debt.  Quick claimed on the stand that he was high on crack at he acted in fear and self defense.

Defense Attorney John Moore argued for third degree murder. He had this reaction after the first degree ruling.  "There was intent to stop Mr. Page from forcing him (Quick) to abandon any other sources of crack cocaine, and his fear Page might enforce that.  But I don't think he saw the final outcome of that as Mr. Page dying."

But Judge Garhart told the court during final arguments that he didn't accept the self defense argument.  In his decision he sided with the prosecution, based on District Attorney Jack Daneri's arguments about the number of brutal blows to the back of the victim's head. "Our theory of the case has been consistent," said Daneri.  "When you take a bat to an individual's head repeatedly you have to have intent to kill him, there can be nothing else."

The victim's brother agreed.  "He meant to kill my brother and he might not of planned on it, but once he hit my brother the first time, he planned on finishing him off," said Jermaine Nixon.

Defense Attorney John Moore said even a third degree verdict would have meant a long time behind bars for Quick. It's a case he calls a lose lose situation.  "Getting involved with something that changes people's behavior as radically as crack does is playing with dynamite every time," said Moore.

The first degree conviction means life in prison without parole. Sentencing is set for March 6.@

Submit your event now
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Drowning Victim Never Reported Missing By Companions

    Drowning Victim Never Reported Missing By Companions

    Monday, July 28 2014 7:16 PM EDT2014-07-28 23:16:32 GMT
    Authorities know more now about the tragic drowning of a teen in Presque Isle Bay. It apparently happened last Thursday, when the boy was in the water with friends, but he was never reported missing. As 12News/SEENews first reported on the weekend, the victim surfaced Saturday morning near the mouth of Cascade Creek. The body of the teen was discovered by fishermen. The coroner identified the victim as 17-year-old Prem Thapa, a Bhutanese immigrant and a student at East High School. We've lear...More >>
    Authorities know more now about the tragic drowning of a teen in Presque Isle Bay. It apparently happened last Thursday, when the boy was in the water with friends, but he was never reported missing. As 12News/SEENews first reported on the weekend, the victim surfaced Saturday morning near the mouth of Cascade Creek. The body of the teen was discovered by fishermen. The coroner identified the victim as 17-year-old Prem Thapa, a Bhutanese immigrant and a student at East High School. We've lear...More >>
  • Man Ejected from Truck in Harborcreek Twp. Accident

    Man Ejected from Truck in Harborcreek Twp. Accident

    Monday, July 28 2014 6:32 PM EDT2014-07-28 22:32:32 GMT
    A man was ejected from his truck in a one-vehicle accident, late this afternoon.More >>
    A man was ejected from his truck in a one-vehicle accident, late this afternoon.More >>
  • Daylight Reveals Scene of Tragic Canoeing Accident

    Daylight Reveals Scene of Tragic Canoeing Accident

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 11:27 AM EDT2014-07-29 15:27:44 GMT
    The waters of Lake Erie have claimed two lives in less than a week. The latest incident, a canoeing trip that turned tragic in western Erie County.More >>
    The waters of Lake Erie have claimed two lives in less than a week. The latest incident, a canoeing trip that turned tragic in western Erie County.
    More >>
  • Fish and Boat Commission Investigates Deadly Canoe Accident

    Fish and Boat Commission Investigates Deadly Canoe Accident

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 7:45 PM EDT2014-07-29 23:45:51 GMT
    The PA Fish and Boat Commission is investigating the circumstances of a deadly canoe accident on Elk Creek Monday night. Waterways Conservation Officer Brook Tolbert says the waters of Elk Creek were high because of heavy rains on Sunday. Tolbert said 53-year old Michael Kohler, and 33-year-old Matthew Kaliszewski were riding that high water when they got into difficulty. Tolbert said they did many things right, including wearing their life jackets, but their trip still ended tragically. The ...More >>
    The PA Fish and Boat Commission is investigating the circumstances of a deadly canoe accident on Elk Creek Monday night. Waterways Conservation Officer Brook Tolbert says the waters of Elk Creek were high because of heavy rains on Sunday. Tolbert said 53-year old Michael Kohler, and 33-year-old Matthew Kaliszewski were riding that high water when they got into difficulty. Tolbert said they did many things right, including wearing their life jackets, but their trip still ended tragically. The ...More >>
  • Man Dead after Canoe Capsizes in Elk Creek

    Man Dead after Canoe Capsizes in Elk Creek

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 4:59 AM EDT2014-07-29 08:59:47 GMT
    A water rescue effort ends with rescue crews finding the body of a 33-year-old man in Elk Creek around 1am on Tuesday morning.More >>
    A water rescue effort ends with rescue crews finding the body of a 33-year-old man in Elk Creek around 1am on Tuesday morning.More >>
  • Man Admits Robbing Three Financial Institutions in Two Weeks

    Man Admits Robbing Three Financial Institutions in Two Weeks

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 5:50 PM EDT2014-07-29 21:50:46 GMT
    Erie Police arrested a man Monday in connection with a bank robbery earlier that afternoon. But it's what the suspect told them that may close a pair of other cases as well.More >>
    Erie Police arrested a man Monday in connection with a bank robbery earlier that afternoon. But it's what the suspect told them that may close a pair of other cases as well.
    More >>
  • "Jax Stone Week" Continues Despite Tragic Passing

    "Jax Stone Week" Continues Despite Tragic Passing

    Monday, July 28 2014 5:50 PM EDT2014-07-28 21:50:10 GMT
    This week has been declared "Jax Stone Week," and despite the sad news of the 9- year- old cancer patient's passing, the fundraising goes on in his name.More >>
    This week has been declared "Jax Stone Week," and despite the sad news of the 9- year- old cancer patient's passing, the fundraising goes on in his name. More >>
  • "Mummies" Take Stage at 8 Great Tuesdays

    "Mummies" Take Stage at 8 Great Tuesdays

    Tuesday, July 29 2014 10:46 PM EDT2014-07-30 02:46:38 GMT
    The skies stayed clear for another 8 Great Tuesdays concert, but what wasn't clear, was who exactly was on the stage.More >>
    The skies stayed clear for another 8 Great Tuesdays concert, but what wasn't clear, was who exactly was on the stage.More >>
Powered by WorldNow
3514 State St. Erie, PA 16508
Newsroom: (814)454-8812
Toll Free: 1(800)454-8812
Business offices: (814)454-5201
WICU FCC Filing
WSEE FCC Filing
Share:
Share Stories
Submit your stories to our site!
Share Photos
Share your photos in our community galleries
Mobile:
Mobile Site
Be sure to stay constantly updated with the power of WICU12 and WSEE at your fingertips
Free Android App
Free iPhone App
Free iPad App
Storm Tracker App
Droid
iPhone
iPad
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WICU. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
                   WICU/WSEE - 3514 State Street Erie, PA 16508 - (814) 454-5201 - info@wicu12.com