Federal Judge Rules PA Marriage Ban Unconstitutional - WICU12 HD WSEE Erie, PA News, Sports, Weather, Events

Federal Judge Rules PA Marriage Ban Unconstitutional

Posted: Updated:
Ban on Marriage Equality Struck Down in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania becomes the tenth state where a federal judge has struck down a marriage ban since historic U.S. Supreme Court decisions last year

WASHINGTON – Today U.S. District Judge John E. Jones, III ruled that Pennsylvania’s law banning marriage equality is unconstitutional. Pennsylvania becomes the tenth state where a federal judge has struck down a marriage ban since the U.S. Supreme Court issued their two marriage-related rulings last year. Just yesterday a federal judge in Oregon struck down that state’s constitutional amendment banning marriage equality. Given the state’s decision not to appeal the ruling, Oregon became the eighteenth where committed and loving gay and lesbian couples can legally marry. In response to today’s news out of Pennsylvania, Human Rights Campaign (HRC) President Chad Griffin issued the following statement:

“Today a federal judge appointed by President George W. Bush became the latest to uphold the most sacred ideals of this nation and our Constitution – that justice and equality matter above all else. It seems that every passing day brings LGBT Americans a new victory in our unwavering march toward justice. And thanks to our friends at the ACLU of PA and ACLU National, the attorneys of Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller, and the proud plaintiffs who brought this case, the inescapable reality of full equality under the law is now one step closer.”

Whitewood v. Wolf was filed on July 9, 2013 by the ACLU of Pennsylvania, the ACLU and counsel from the law firm of Hangley Aronchick Segal Pudlin & Schiller on behalf of 21 Pennsylvanians seeking the right to marry or for the Commonwealth to recognize their out-of-state marriages. The suit challenges a law passed by the state legislature in 1996 that restricts marriage to the union of one man and one woman.

In July of 2013, state attorney general Kathleen Kane announced she would not defend the state’s marriage ban. If PA Gov. Tom Corbett decides not to appeal today’s ruling, the Keystone State would become the nineteenth state with marriage equality, plus Washington, D.C. With Pennsylvania, nearly 44 percent of Americans would live in states where gay and lesbian couples can legally marry.


To date there have been at least six marriage cases filed in Pennsylvania, two in federal court and four in state court. Pennsylvania was the only remaining state in the Northeast without marriage equality. A March 2014 Washington Post-ABC News poll showed 59 percent of Americans support marriage equality.

In today’s ruling, Judge Jones wrote, “We are a better people than what these laws represent, and it is time to discard them into the ash heap of history.”

Whitewood is one of over 70 marriage equality cases working their way through the judicial system across the country. These cases have been filed in 29 states plus Puerto Rico and account for hundreds of plaintiffs taking on state marriage bans. So far five federal appeals courts are presiding over nine marriage equality cases over the coming weeks and months. Same-sex couples can legally marry in eighteen states and the District of Columbia, while 32 states have a law or constitutional amendment restricting marriage to the union of one man and one woman.


Not everybody agrees with the ruling though.


Pennsylvania Family Institute Disagrees with Court Decision Redefining Marriage in Pennsylvania
Decision Undermines Family, Challenges Liberty & Diminishes Respect for the Law

(Harrisburg, PA) Tuesday, MAY 19, 2014 For Immediate Release

Despite today’s decision by United States District Judge John E. Jones III, the Pennsylvania Family Institute reaffirms its conviction that the long-standing definition of marriage between one man and one woman is not only constitutional, but essential to a free and flourishing society.

“This decision tosses aside not just the definition of marriage recognized in law by an overwhelming majority of the people’s representatives, but the definition that has been in place in Pennsylvania since our commonwealth’s founding more than two centuries ago,” said PFI president Michael Geer.

“Children have a right to a mother and a father,” Geer continued, “and that is a right that government is bound to respect and should encourage. Today’s decision abandons that responsibility in favor of a new framework that places the desires of adults above the good of children and society as a whole,” added Geer.

Randall Wenger, PFI Chief Counsel stated: “Today’s decision threatens the rights of those who believe marriage is between a man and a woman. As Americans we should be free to debate and decide issues of critical social importance. Judicial decrees like today’s marginalize those who understand what is special and indeed vital about this institution -- natural marriage -- that brings a man and a woman together for children.”

Marriage between one man and one woman has no parallels. Social science tells us there is nothing so beneficial to the well being of children as a mom and a dad committed to each other in marriage. This standard should be encouraged – not redefined and dismissed in favor of a new social experiment that could negatively impact children and families.

PFI’s Brandon McGinley pointed out, “This ruling short-circuits the public debate and legitimate policy process, and casts aside the will of the people of Pennsylvania and their elected representatives. This can only foster further distrust of our political system.”

The Pennsylvania Family Institute calls on Governor Tom Corbett to appeal this decision, and to make a vigorous defense of the fundamental institution of marriage at the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.

Despite the setback, the Pennsylvania Family Institute will continue to fight for public policy that’s best for children and families. “Our work is only more urgent in the wake of today’s decision,” said Geer.

Submit your event now
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Motorcyclist Killed in Girard Township

    Motorcyclist Killed in Girard Township

    Sunday, August 31 2014 7:11 PM EDT2014-08-31 23:11:54 GMT
    State police in Girard are investigating a deadly car and motorcycle collision that happened just before noon Sunday. Police cited the driver of the car for pulling out from a stop sign into the path of the motorcycle.It happened at the intersection of Route 20 and Elk Park Road. State police say 21-year-old Ashley Carpinello of Girard was on Elk Park, stopped at a stop sign when she pulled her Suzuki sedan directly into the path of a westbound motorcycle on Route 20. The driver, 58-year-old...More >>
    State police in Girard are investigating a deadly car and motorcycle collision that happened just before noon Sunday. Police cited the driver of the car for pulling out from a stop sign into the path of the motorcycle.It happened at the intersection of Route 20 and Elk Park Road. State police say 21-year-old Ashley Carpinello of Girard was on Elk Park, stopped at a stop sign when she pulled her Suzuki sedan directly into the path of a westbound motorcycle on Route 20. The driver, 58-year-old...More >>
  • Heavy Rains Cause Flooding Concerns For Erie Residents

    Heavy Rains Cause Flooding Concerns For Erie Residents

    Sunday, August 31 2014 11:53 PM EDT2014-09-01 03:53:42 GMT
    In the midst of Sunday's heavy downpours, neighbors describe it looks like during a storm on the corner of Stafford and Walnut Street on Erie's west side.More >>
    In the midst of Sunday's heavy downpours, neighbors describe it looks like during a storm on the corner of Stafford and Walnut Street on Erie's west side.More >>
  • Fatal Crash In Crawford County

    Fatal Crash In Crawford County

    Sunday, August 31 2014 10:03 AM EDT2014-08-31 14:03:42 GMT
    State police are investigating a fatal accident in Crawford County.More >>
    State police are investigating a fatal accident in Crawford County.
    More >>
  • Local Filmmaker Shoots Horror Film in Erie

    Local Filmmaker Shoots Horror Film in Erie

    Sunday, August 31 2014 5:56 PM EDT2014-08-31 21:56:42 GMT
    Erie's Glenwood Heights neighborhood was turned into a movie set Sunday afternoon for the upcoming independent film,"Blink of an Eye."More >>
    Erie's Glenwood Heights neighborhood was turned into a movie set Sunday afternoon for the upcoming independent film,"Blink of an Eye."More >>
  • Canadian Teen Sets Out On Last Leg of Swim

    Canadian Teen Sets Out On Last Leg of Swim

    Monday, September 1 2014 12:11 AM EDT2014-09-01 04:11:22 GMT
    Over the years several local swimmers have crossed Lake Erie from Long Point, Ontario to Erie County's shores. In July Annaleise Carr, a 16-year-old Canadian swimmer was going the other way, starting in Erie and ending in Port Dover with a goal of making the longest Lake Erie swim crossing in history. She successfully crossed the lake, but didn't go as far as her own personal goal. She suspended the swim in Long Point. This weekend she's trying to make good on her pledge to finish the span an...More >>
    Over the years several local swimmers have crossed Lake Erie from Long Point, Ontario to Erie County's shores. In July Annaleise Carr, a 16-year-old Canadian swimmer was going the other way, starting in Erie and ending in Port Dover with a goal of making the longest Lake Erie swim crossing in history. She successfully crossed the lake, but didn't go as far as her own personal goal. She suspended the swim in Long Point. This weekend she's trying to make good on her pledge to finish the span an...More >>
  • Vacant Home on Sterrettania Road Goes Up in Flames

    Vacant Home on Sterrettania Road Goes Up in Flames

    Sunday, August 31 2014 6:08 PM EDT2014-08-31 22:08:46 GMT
    A vacant home on Sterrettania Road went up in flames Sunday morning.
    More >>
    A vacant home on Sterrettania Road went up in flames Sunday morning. happened.
    More >>
  • Community Comes Together to Help Local Mom Battling Rare Form of Cancer

    Community Comes Together to Help Local Mom Battling Rare Form of Cancer

    Saturday, August 30 2014 6:38 PM EDT2014-08-30 22:38:13 GMT
    The community is coming together to help a local mom battling a rare and aggressive form of thyroid cancer.More >>
    The community is coming together to help a local mom battling a rare and aggressive form of thyroid cancer.More >>
  • Motorcyclist Crushed After Colliding With Semi Truck

    Motorcyclist Crushed After Colliding With Semi Truck

    Thursday, August 28 2014 10:37 AM EDT2014-08-28 14:37:38 GMT
    "He hits his brakes, somehow goes down on the motorcycle and somehow goes underneath the tires," Sgt. Traffic Investigator Jeff Annunziata says.It was 5:30p.m. Wednesday evening, when police say a 53-year old man from Millcreek, who has not yet been identified, fails to brake in time for a semi truck traveling eastbound on West 12th Street.More >>
    "He hits his brakes, somehow goes down on the motorcycle and somehow goes underneath the tires," Sgt. Traffic Investigator Jeff Annunziata says.It was 5:30p.m. Wednesday evening, when police say a 53-year old man from Millcreek, who has not yet been identified, fails to brake in time for a semi truck traveling eastbound on West 12th Street. More >>
Powered by WorldNow
3514 State St. Erie, PA 16508
Newsroom: (814)454-8812
Toll Free: 1(800)454-8812
Business offices: (814)454-5201
WICU FCC Filing
WSEE FCC Filing
Share:
Share Stories
Submit your stories to our site!
Share Photos
Share your photos in our community galleries
Mobile:
Mobile Site
Be sure to stay constantly updated with the power of WICU12 and WSEE at your fingertips
Free Android App
Free iPhone App
Free iPad App
Storm Tracker App
Droid
iPhone
iPad
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WICU. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
                   WICU/WSEE - 3514 State Street Erie, PA 16508 - (814) 454-5201 - info@wicu12.com