San Francisco to remove what's been called a 'racist and disresp - Erie News Now | WICU & WSEE in Erie, PA

San Francisco to remove what's been called a 'racist and disrespectful' statue

Posted: Updated:
This San Francisco statue will be removed after complaints that it's degrading to Native Americans. This San Francisco statue will be removed after complaints that it's degrading to Native Americans.
By Madison Park CNN

(CNN) -- The controversial statue that critics have deemed as "San Francisco's monument to white supremacy" is coming off its pedestal.

The bronze statue that shows a partially clothed Native American man at the feet of two men -- a cowboy and a Catholic missionary -- will be plucked from its prominent location in San Francisco in a process that begins in coming weeks.

To its critics, the bronze statue called "Early Days" is an offensive and condescending depiction of Native Americans that fails to acknowledge racism, colonization and genocide.

And this week, the San Francisco Arts Commission unanimously agreed to remove "Early Days" from the city's Pioneer Monument, which contains a cluster of five statues.

"This racist and disrespectful sculpture has no place in the heart of our city," the commission said in a statement.

Efforts to remove "Early Days" started in the 1990s when the group of statues were being moved to construct a new main library. Some Native Americans wanted the whole monument and especially "Early Days" gone. Instead, the statues along with "Early Days" were moved to their current location with a new plaque that explained the history of what happened to California's Native Americans.

"This plaque has been covered up by plants for many years, and does not offer an explanation of the historical context of these racist images, and does not extend any apology for the theft of land, colonization, subjugation, and near-annihilation of Native American people," according to the "Take Down the Pioneer Statue" Facebook group that has sought to get rid of the statue.

The controversy resurfaced last year over the uproar over Confederate monuments in the South. Almost immediately after the events in Charlottesville in August, the San Francisco Arts Commission began receiving public requests to remove "Early Days."

The statue is to be taken down and placed in storage with an estimated cost of $160,000 to $200,000. A plaque will be placed near where it once stood explaining why it has been taken down, according to the Arts Commission.

"It's important for us to respect and honor the original inhabitants of this land and to remember that they remain a part of our community today and their voices deserve to be heard," said Tom DeCaigny, the commission's director of cultural affairs, in a statement.

Some commenters on the commission's Facebook page criticized the decision as censorship and political correctness taken too far.

"Early Days" was created by California artist Frank Happersberger who completed the Pioneer Monument in 1894. The work was to pay tribute to California's history including the early settlement of the mission.

CNN's Sonya Hamasaki contributed to this report.

TM & © 2018 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

Powered by Frankly
3514 State St. Erie, PA 16508
Newsroom: (814) 454-8812
Business offices: (814) 454-5201
Share Stories
Submit your stories to our site!
Share Photos
Share your photos in our community galleries
RSS Feeds
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2018 WICU. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.
                   WICU/WSEE - 3514 State Street Erie, PA 16508 - (814) 454-5201 -